Vanishings - Mysterious Cases Of Missing People
80
Where have they gone? What is their fate?
Every year, all over the world, there are thousands of people who go missing - children, teenagers, adults and the elderly. Most cases are resolved easily and quickly. However, there are many past and present that have never been solved. In addition the circumstances surrounding their disappearance are, in some cases, bizarre. And the fate of these unfortunate people may be destined to remain within the realms of speculation and rumour forever.
The Flannan Isles Mystery
The Flannan Isles is a beautiful location off the North West coast of Scotland. They are part of the larger group of Islands - the Outer Hebrides. The Flannans are also known as the Seven Hunters. Apart from the lighthouse, the islands are mainly a habitat for wildlife. It is this lighthouse that gave rise to one of the most puzzling mysteries in the UK files of missing people.
The year is 1900 and about one week before Christmas. Not one person went missing from the isolated light house but three - James Ducat, Thomas Marshall and Donald MacArthur. It was a ship on route from Philadelphia to Edinburgh that raised the first alarm. On passing the lighthouse the crew noticed that the light was not working and reported the matter as soon as they docked.
Finally, a relief boat - The Hesperus - arrived at the island on December 26th 1900. Captain Jim Harvie had the whole island searched in addition to the lighthouse. But the men could not be found.
The search party began a more exhaustive investigation, searching for any clues that would point to the source of the keepers' disappearance. Looking in all areas of the lighthouse they noticed nothing out of place. The work for the 15th December had all been completed - machines cleaned and oiled, lunch plates, pots and pans washed, kitchen tidied. These observations pointed to the fact that the men probably disappeared sometime in the afternoon after they had eaten lunch; as no further cooking had been carried out for the evening. A search of the sleeping quarters showed that their beds had not been slept in. The clocks in the light house had all stopped. The doors and windows were secure and showed no sign of damage. The mystified search party completed a report on their findings and left the island.
The main theory then put forward was that a recent savage storm had been responsible in some way, for their disapperance. However, the lighthouse keeper's last log was dated 15 December - this was at least 24 hours after the storm had passed. One of the keepers had also recorded in the log what outside damage had been caused by the ferocious winds. When the news broke that the keepers were alive after the storm abated, all manner of theories and rumours erupted.
Some of theories given were:
- Despite the date, the storm was in some way responsible - the most likely theory was that the keepers had been swept out to sea.
- A freak wave or other natural phenomena had caught the keepers off guard - most likely causing them to be drowned.
- One of the keepers had murdered the other two and then committed suicide. Although there doesn't seem to be any reason to think that the keepers were other than friendly with one another.
- A sea serpent or other monster was seriously considered. Up until this time there had been hundreds of reports from all over the world about huge sea serpents/monsters that could swallow ships whole. Most of these accounts have proved to be misidentifcations and hearsay.
- The light house keepers had been kidnapped by spies. This is unlikely as no ransom money or any other demand was made for the mens' return.
- The light house keepers had been murdered by persons unknown. One theory put forward was that the murders were committed by a ghostly crew from a phantom ship! Leaving the spooks aside, if murder was the cause then it was the cleanest one ever committed. There was no sign of trauma, blood or violence of any kind. In addition, robbery is highly unlikely as nothing was taken.
It might have been expected that at least one of the bodies would have shown up - either washed ashore or discovered in another location. However, no trace of the men were ever found. So intriguing is this mystery that not only songs and poems have been written about it, but an opera also.
Vanished Into Thin Air?
Is it possible for human beings to be there one moment and then gone the next?
Most of us, quite rightly would conclude that this is not possible. And yet if we research this subject it is surprising how many stories there are, seemingly by credible witnesses, who claim this is exactly what has happened. One of the most remarkable cases of one such disapperance - if not into thin air - was certainly while in the air.
Bass Strait, Australia - 1978
The disappearance of a young man named Frederick Valentich on October 21st 1978 is still one of the most mysterious and frightening.
Frederick was flying his Cessna 182L aircraft over an area called Bass Strait In Australia. It was a straight forward journey to pick up some friends from King Island.
During the flight Frederick was in two-way radio contact with the Melbourne Flight Service Unit. It is these recorded conversations that give the last chilling details before Frederick and his plane vanished.
The 6 minute transcript details Frederick's description of an unidentified craft he was observing. He was asked on several occasions by Melbourne to identify the craft but he could not. At one stage Frederick reported that "it was playing games". The object would disappear for a few seconds the return from a different direction. Frederick could still not identify the craft because of the speed it was traveling at. He then reported that the object was approaching him again. A few seconds later he reported that it was now above him, but also that his engine was playing up. Then he spoke his last words: "It's not an aircraft"
A massive search and rescue mission was launched but neither the craft nor the pilot's body was ever recovered. The Australian Department of Transport's conclusion of the investigation stated that the reason for the disappearance of the pilot and his craft could not be determined.
A number of theories were put forward to explain what happened to the young pilot but all remain, understandably, inconclusive. The well respected and experienced researcher Dr Richard Haines, who worked for NASA, took a keen interest in the case and came up with four possible conclusions:
- Pilot disorientation/crash/death - this particular conclusion was not favoured by Dr Haines.
- Deliberate hoax/suicide - Dr Haines, Frederick's family and friends all state catergorically that this would be out of character for the young man and there is no evidence to suggest a hoax or that Frederick was attempting suicide.
- UFO and/or UFO in-flight abduction - Dr Richard Haines did not feel that this was the most likely reason for the pilot's disappearance but other reputable researchers have concluded that it is possible given the observations made by the pilot.
- Military Weapons' Test - this is the theory most favoured by Dr Haines as being the most likely given the evidence. However, a number of other researchers feel that this conclusion is based purely on speculation rather than fact.
To this day, Frederick's disappearance remains a mystery. Theories will continue to be put forward, but this seems to be one modern case destined to remain unsolved.
The Weird Disappearance of a Paralysed Man.
Shepton Mallet, Somerset - England.
One of the most baffling disappearances has to be that of the retired sailor, Owen Parfitt from his home in 1763.
Parfitt shared a home with his older sister in the small country town of Shepton Mallet. In his younger days he was a sailor. But it's also alleged that he was involved in a number of dubious practices such as - piracy, smuggling and black magic. He was also a known womaniser. There are references to a scandal that broke out, involving his much younger cousin called Dorothy.
It's not known exactly when Parfitt suffered a stroke. However, the condition left him unable to move on his own and he was cared for by his sister. She was assisted by a friend a night as two people were needed to get the now 60 year old Parfitt in and out of bed.
Frequently during the day and in the evenings, Parfitt would sit outside the house wearing just a nightshirt and was kept upright by placing his old great coat underneath him. But on one particular evening he simply vanished. While many farm hands were working in the fields next to the house and his sister was inside, Parfitt mysteriously disappeared. The alarm was raised when his sister's friend came to help her put Parfitt into bed. The two women went outside to assist him in, but there was nothing there except the great coat. Helped by the farm hands a thorough search was made in the area, but no trace of him was found.
His sister maintained that he was spirited away by the Devil because of his lurid past. Other rumours suggested that he was kidnapped and made to reveal the hiding place of buried treasure he had stolen during his days as a pirate. But kidnapping was ruled out as neither his sister nor the many farm workers close by, had heard any noise of a struggle or violence. Moreover the place where Parfitt was sitting was not disturbed - his great coat that was used to keep him upright, was still in the same position as his sister had placed it earlier that day.
The mystery seemed to have been solved however, when in 1813 alterations were being made to a property close to Parfitt's home. Behind the fireplace a skeleton of what was reported to be 'a crippled old man' was found. However, on examination the skeleton was found to be that of a young woman. This of course is another mystery as foul play was suspected in her case. Even more intriguing is the fact that the building was once a house belonging to Parfitt's young cousin Dorothy - the same lady he had allegedly had an affair with many years previously.
Investigations into the case continued right into the 20th century - 1933 being the last recorded investigation - but the case remains a mystery to this day.
Conclusions
There is no doubt that people will continue to vanish in mysterious circumstances - in fact throughout the world, there are thousands of people who go missing every year, never to be found. Some will perhaps be solved. But others, such as the Valentich and Parfitt cases, are likely to remain an enigma. In addition, there are some factors that may point to the unsettling conclusion that other forces may be at work - are these strange aspects the real reason for so many mysterious vanishings?
Further Information & Sources
- The Disappearance of Frederick Valentich | Historic Mysteries
Frederick Valentich was an Australian pilot who disappeared on October 21, 1978. His disappearance is surrounded by mystery, controversy and skepticism. - UFO Evidence - Scientific Study of the UFO Phenomenon
UFOEVIDENCE.ORG presents in-depth and quality research, resources and information on the UFO phenomenon. It is one of the largest internet sites on the UFO subject. - Shepton Mallet Town Council, Welcome to Shepton Mallet
Shepton Mallet Town Council - The Times | UK News, World News and Opinion
News and opinion from The Times, sign up now and get your first 30 days access for £1 - Transcripts of documents from the Flannan Isles
Museum of Scottish Lighhouses. - BBC News | SCOTLAND | Flannan mystery remembered
A one-minute silence is observed in memory of three lighthouse keepers who disappeared without trace 100 years ago. - Scotland Here And Now
- Flannan Isles Travel Guide - Scotland
Flannan Isles Scotland - plan your perfect trip to Flannan Isles with our guides to top accommodation, places to eat, and local attractions
vote upvote downshareprintflag
- Useful (4)
- Funny
- Awesome (3)
- Beautiful
- Interesting (12)
CommentsLoading...
Fascinating I enjoyed reading this. There are so many people go missing and never have been found. It is vertainly a mystery.
A great hub and well laid out.
voted up
This is all fascinating. Thanks for sharing these stories.
Very interesting hub, I enjoyed reading all about those people disappearing.
Interesting cases.
So strange...fascinating stories. The one about the paralyzed man especially intrigues me. More, please.
Frightening stories Seeker 7. The fact that people can just disappear out of the blue is spooky. I wonder if we will ever find out the truth behind theses disappearances.
Very interesting hub. I wonder, like I know many people, of why this happens. Without a trace is the way law enforcement will often describe it. I have prayed for the family that I do not know many times because I would hate to have one of my loved one vanish into thin air. Voted up and interesting.
Absolutely fascinating. Who knows maybe there somewhere beyond these boundaries and before the next life's boundaries there's a world where these people now live in spirit. We will never know but eventually it may be popular to start saying oh, really? Did he just leave or did he disappear?
Sad but also very interesting.
I am sure that many will benefit from reading this one.
Take care and have a great day.
Eiddwen.
As one who always wanted to be a detective, this article fascinated me. It must frustrate the heck out of the investigators when no clue at all ever surfaces.
And yes, it must be horrible to be a relative of the vanished one.
These were very interesting stories. My wife and I both are interested in this subject. It seems more and more, we hear about these strange disappearances. I enjoyed reading this. I think I would lean towards the UFO theory involving the airplane. There are so many reports of UFOs all over the world, there has to be something to this.
What an absolutely astonishing hub.
I am flabbergasted. Where do all these people go?
Just walk out of their lives and vanish.
Great work seeker7 voted up




















Alastar Packer Level 8 Commenter 7 months ago
These are some great mysteries to write on Seeker. Always done exceptionally well by you too. The lighthouse keepers disappearance on the Scottish isle is a real humdinger of a mystery. I think the same thing happened to them what happened to Fredrick Valentine. There's no question but that Valentine and his plane were scooped up by a UFO. The bizarre back and forth with air traffic control, including the 17 second weird noise at the end; radar and eyewitnesses too. For all the nay-sayers he still hasn't turned up in 33 years and the planes never been found either. A very solid UFO abduction. The only mystery is what they did with him. Paralyzed Man is a new one here. Its an enigma, inside a riddle, wrapped up in a mystery alright. Thanks a mil for another great paranormal read Seeker7!